Reading FC

| View Comments (14)
Which areas does Brian McDermott need to strengthen for Reading FC to succeed in the Premier League?
Which areas does Brian McDermott need to strengthen for Reading FC to succeed in the Premier League?
advertisement

Where do Reading FC need to strengthen?

By Jonny Fordham
May 10, 2012

Work has already started on planning for life in the Premier League at Madejski Stadium.

Manager Brian McDermott and director of football Nick Hammond have a wish-list of players drawn up.

McDermott has already spoken of bringing in at least three players ready for the start of pre-season training in July, but what areas do Royals need to strengthen?

 

Goalkeepers

Undoubtedly Reading’s strongest position – in first-choice keeper Adam Federici , McDermott has a player destined for an exciting career in the top flight.

In reserve former England Under-21 stopper Alex McCarthy proved his credentials against Everton and Manchester City in the FA Cup last season.

Danish star Mikkel Andersen also has international experience with the Under-21s and although is yet to make his Royals debut, the 23-year-old is another highly thought of talent.

McDermott’s man-management skills will again no doubt come into play with McCarthy and Andersen both keen to play at the highest level possible.

McCarthy will keep his understudy position behind Australian Federici, but Andersen could head out on loan to a Championship club to keep his own career moving.

Verdict: Royals will be the envy of most Premier League side’s with their stable of keepers next season and McDermott won’t need to spend any money between the sticks.

 

Defenders

In Kaspars Gorkss, Royals have a top-quality centre-back and leader at the heart of their back four.

Although Ian Harte is the only player in the rearguard with Premier League experience, Gorkss has played at the highest level captaining Latvia.

And Alex Pearce alongside him at centre-back has grown in stature in the past 12 months.

Right-back Shaun Cummings has the talent to cut it at the highest level and will be another player who develops with the experience of top flight football.

The lack of pace in Reading’s back-four is glaringly obvious and this will be an area where Royals could come undone.

What Harte lacks in pace he more than makes up for in positional sense and it is that nous that his team-mates will also need to show.

Beyond the current first-choice defenders McDermott has very little in reserve.

Centre-back Sean Morrison has done well at Huddersfield on loan, but he has yet to play in the Championship.

Joseph Mills has been hit and miss in the Championship, but he managed to find his feet and show some form before injuries got the better of him around Christmas time.

The likes of Michael Hector and Angus MacDonald continue to progress well out on loan in League Two, but they are not ready for Premier League football.

Verdict: Someone like Matthew Connolly from Queens Park Rangers would provide perfect cover and competition across the back four.

Another proven centre-back or right-back would also be a good addition to the 25-man squad.

 

Midfielders

Mikele Leigertwood and Jem Karacan are likely to be McDermott’s first-choice central pairing, but both are defensive minded.

Jay Tabb is the main competition at the moment, so Royals could do with another central player to add cover with doubts over Brynjar Gunnarsson’s future.

There is talent waiting in the wings with Lawson D’Ath and Jake Taylor, but neither are ready for this kind of stage just yet.

In wide areas Jobi McAnuff and Jimmy Kebe should thrive on the big stage and Hal Robson-Kanu is ready for this opportunity having played at international level for Wales.

Michail Antonio has been brilliant on loan at Sheffield Wednesday this season, but his five goals in 14 games have all been in League One.

The 22-year-old has raw ability, but lacks the technical side of the game he would need in the Premier League right now.

Jordan Obita, the 18-year-old winger, is an exciting talent, but he too will need more time to mature as a player in the lower leagues.

Verdict: A creative midfielder as well as another wide player would give Royals’ added flair to the midfield.

 

Strikers

Jason Roberts came to Reading to play Premier League football and he now has his wish.

Although Roberts will miss the first two games of the season, he will most likely still be Reading’s number one hitman next season.

Noel Hunt has SPL and international experience and Simon Church has also played for his country.

However, neither have been consistent scorers for Royals, but both have had to sacrifice their own talents for the sake of the team at times.

Adam Le Fondre is the most clinical striker of the lot, but he may again be used more as an impact player rather than starting games.

Mathieu Manset, currently on loan at Shanghai, will be back at the club come pre-season, but his 18-months at Madejski Stadium have been more miss than hit.

Outside of those five players, Karl Sheppard has yet to make his debut, likewise with Brett Williams, who has spent the final half of the season on loan at Northampton Town.

So neither of those two forwards look likely to feature much in the Premier League, it at all.

Verdict: At least one striker with proven Premier League experience, or international pedigree, would be a big coup for McDermott and inspire the fans.

If Roberts gets injured then Royals could end up looking lost in attack, such is his importance to the team.

| View Comments (14)
advertisement

We are no longer accepting comments on this article.

Most recent user comments 14 of 14

   We need players in the midfield, central defense and up front who want to keep the ball. We are good at chasing it down but not so good at holding onto it for a while. I suppose Roberts and Jimmy are good at that. We need to be able to keep the ball for longer periods because we will spend much longer trying to get it back in the prem. Agree with the article pretty much. Quality striker would be good. Rhodes at Huddersfield is clearly a good striker but.. remember Everton's signing of Beckford? Might be taking a gamble with him.
poru, Bournemouth
11/05/2012 at 15:53 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   Three defenders - right back (we have no cover), centre back (we have no cover) and left back (neither of the current two are likely to be ready to play regularly at this standard)

Attacking midfieder - haven't had one of those for years!

Cover on the wing - unless Antonio is considered a possibility, and MOST DEFINITELY

A forward - proven at Premiership level. Cover for Roberts, Hunt and Le Fondre

So I reckon we will have at least 6 new players by the end of august.
come on lads
11/05/2012 at 13:30 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   A tricky ask if you want maintain that team spirit. The players who got us there should be given fair chance to prove themselves and not be immediately demoted to a 'squad player'
Lester Crinklesack
11/05/2012 at 12:10 Offensive or Inappropriate?
    i think we need a left back, bertrand would be great. we need a centre back of quality pace and experience, i wonder whether kebe and macnuff is consistant enough on the wing and whether mikele is good enough in this division, and whether jem is creative enough or even if he will be the same player when he comes back from injury. we need two strikers as mr roberts isn't getting any younger and will he stay fit. i don't believe churchy, alfie or manset are good enough.

whatever happens i believe the players to be brought in need to be good enough to go straight into the first eleven otherwise its a case of having your highest earners sat on their a!!!e. which can only be bad for the morale of the squad. at least one of them should be a marque signing to make other teams take notice and better players want to join.
ajr111, swindon
10/05/2012 at 18:45 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   I agree with Brian (in the photo)...we need 5 players.
Lester Crinklesack
10/05/2012 at 14:36 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   It is clear to most of us that being good in the championship will not cust the mustard in the prem! So we def need a left back cos I can run past Harte, we also need a decent centre back with pace - Curtis Davies mould. In the middle we need flair agreed, someone who can move the ball quickly to the wingers and see that pass through the middle to open up a defence. And up front we need another quality striker. So minimal 4 quality signings IMO. I hate to say it but we need to get rid of a few as well - Church, Tabb fit in too the championship at best, and I also believe that Gunnarsson should be released even tho he has been a great ambassador at the club. We do need more quality and which should all be realistic this team is not as good as the 2006 team.....at the moment!!
LoughboroughRoyal, Loughborough
10/05/2012 at 13:21 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   IMO We need a Left Back, a Centre Arf, attacking midfielder and a Proven goal scorer. This is the minimum requirements and without, are stay could be shorter than the last one.
Tilidie, Reading
10/05/2012 at 12:04 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   RSwanny, Anton can't get his chequebook out because we don't seem to have SEEN his chequebook yet-the absence of the "TSI deal being completed this week" story that has graced the post for, I believe, Six out of the last Seven Weeks is GLARYINGLY obvious-and concerning!!

Or has Fordham finally found something constructive to speculate about???
Lionel Messi's Right Foot, Reading
10/05/2012 at 11:16 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   If we continue with two holding midfielders and two wingers then I reckon we would definately require another midfielder possibly more creative as a plan b.

Assuming Connolly signs he can play RB & CB - But Really think we need a CB & LB we got lucky with Gorkks & Pearce neither being injured or suspended with more pace & guile in the Prem another season of this seems unlikely. Harte can do the job but Mills I am not convinced about so another LB.

Another Striker could well be required as who knows what will happen to Manset -- I cannot see Church being ditched he is well thought of and despite many fans rather lukewarm opinion the only way I can see Church leaving us is if he is part of a deal that brings someone like Whittingham from Cardiff??

If Antonio moves on to Wednesday then maybe a winger if not then we have 5 including Obita and even Hunty can play there at times.

I reckon Mullins & Connolly plus another 2 or 3 will be all we will see.

URZ
Robsy , Reading
10/05/2012 at 10:57 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   The takeover of the club which was to be completed by the end of March has now gone on long enough. Every week the story is next week it will be done. Is it still ongoing or has it collapsed. If it has then the numbers players coming in will be sharply reduced.
arreff, North Wales
10/05/2012 at 10:51 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   Next season and in this order, i want to see:

Decent coffee on sale (Latte), Kebe being able to run more than 100yrds without falling over and a striker who will a score minimum of 20goals a season.
love buddha, Berkshire
10/05/2012 at 10:22 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   Think we need 1 du , 1wq ,2 fg ,7pl Apart from that all good
deejaykay, Tilehurst
10/05/2012 at 10:19 Offensive or Inappropriate?
    Great read - would agree with all of it but add:

I would say we need - 1 RB, 1 LB, 2 CB, 1 RW, 2 MID, 2 FWD - only 9 players, get your cheque book out Anton! :)
RSwanny, Bristol
10/05/2012 at 10:11 Offensive or Inappropriate?
   What about taking a punt on Man City's Owen Hargreaves seems he wont be getting a contract next season could be worth a gamble on fitness with a "pay as you play " type of contract, with maybe a good bonus if Reading stay up
A. XYZ
10/05/2012 at 10:09 Offensive or Inappropriate?
 
Homes / Jobs Search
 
Jobs Homes

Brought to you by

Fish4jobs
Newsletter Sign Up
 
Sign up to the
weekly news
update


Submit
Loading poll, please wait...